Pros of Bell Training | Cons of Bell Training |
Empowers dogs to communicate their needs clearly and directly | Some dogs will ring the bell whenever they want to play outside, not just for pottying |
For many pet parents, a bell chiming is a better alert than barking or scratching at the door | If your dog uses their paw to ring the bell, they could damage the door or walls (which is why a nose nudge is usually preferable) |
Better communication fosters a strong bond and reduces frustration for dogs and pet parents | Takes time for training to stick |
Works well for dogs of all sizes, ages, and breeds | Pet parents may miss other signals that a dog needs to go potty |
Bell Training FAQs
If you’re struggling with bell training after several weeks, here are some troubleshooting tips and advice.
Should I ring the bell during training?
While some experts advise pet parents to ring the bell every time they take their dogs out, Reynolds says this doesn’t necessarily help the dog learn to communicate autonomously. “It is important that your dog learns early on that they control the sound of the bell,” he adds.
What if my dog rings the bell when they want to go outside?
“One way to discourage indiscriminate ringing is to give access to the bell only when there is a high likelihood of your dog needing to potty, such as after meals, naps, or playtime,” Reynolds explains. Pet parents can dial up the praise when their pups use the bell as intended. Bring them back inside if they don’t go potty after several minutes.
Is it bad if I ignore the bell?
Reynolds says that failing to respond immediately when your dog rings the bell can weaken their training. Always take them out right away to create a clear association between the bell and potty time.
What happens if the bell rings at other times?
“We call this ‘poisoning the cue,’ which means the cue (in this case, bell ringing) isn’t clear enough,” Keast explains. You may need to adjust the bell’s location so it’s not being rung accidentally or outside of potty time.
Are there consequences to skipping the bell?
While pet parents might think skipping the bell isn’t a big deal, Keast sats this can send your puppy mixed messages and make the bell training longer.
What training method should I use alongside bell training?
Positive reinforcement is the primary training method to use with bell training. “Potty breaks and going outside are their own reward, but for most puppies, nothing beats a treat,” Keast explains.
If you’re stuck, call in a professional trainer to help your pup get on board with bell training. However, bell training may not be the best potty training method in some cases. “If your dog isn’t responding to the bell or is actively avoiding it, it may be time to look at a different way for them to tell you they need to go outside,” Keast says. To that end, it’s helpful to learn your dog’s schedule and cues so you can better anticipate their needs.
Takeaway
Dogs of all sizes, ages, and types can master the potty bell in a few weeks of consistent training. As always, patience and consistency are the keys to success. “Some puppies will learn faster than others, and some may regress after they seem to get it,” Keast says. She encourages pet parents to stick with it—most dogs will catch on with practice and plenty of positive reinforcement.
Pet Parent Resources
Looking for a loving sitter to care for your potty-trained pup? Explore Rover’s pet care services from dog walkers to boarding facilities to find an experienced sitter in your neighborhood.